Client Update: The end of the unit trust monopoly – tranche 1 of the revised CCIV bill
15 June 2018
In brief: On 13 June 2018, the Federal Government released the first tranche of the revised exposure draft legislation for the new corporate collective investment vehicle, one of the two forms of collective investment vehicle which it pledged to develop as part of the 2016-2017 budget. We are undertaking a comprehensive review of the draft for the purpose of preparing submissions to Treasury and will provide further updates in due course. In the meantime, Partner Penny Nikoloudis (view CV), Senior Overseas Practitioner James Kanabar and Associate Mai Go provide a high-level overview of the draft.
As we have previously reported, on the recommendation of the 2009 Johnson Report and the findings from the 2015 Board of Taxation's report, on 25 August 2017 the Federal Government released the first exposure draft of the legislation introducing the proposed corporate collective investment vehicle (CCIV Bill). The purpose of the CCIV regime (timed to coincide with the introduction of the new Asia Region Funds Passport) is to introduce a form of investment vehicle that both retains the tax flow-through treatment of the unit trust, and which is also more familiar to offshore investors, to assist Australian fund managers to compete for capital more effectively with their offshore counterparts. That theme was encapsulated by The Hon Kelly O'Dwyer MP in her remarks accompanying the release of the revised draft CCIV Bill:
“The CCIV vehicle will allow Australian fund managers to market to participating Asian financial markets using a well-recognised corporate structure vehicle — creating access to Asia’s expanding middle and upper class."
Following consultation on the CCIV Bill last year, the Federal Government has now released for consultation the first tranche of the revised draft of the CCIV Bill (Revised CCIV Bill), addressing amendments to:
- the proposed new Chapter 8B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), which establishes the regulatory framework for CCIVs; and
- ensure the correct application of Chapters 2A to 2P of the Corporations Act to CCIVs; and
- the explanatory materials to incorporate a summary of the proposed legislative approach to depositary independence.
In the course of considering the Revised CCIV Bill more closely, we will provide further updates as our review proceeds. Below is a preliminary overview of some of the key changes that have been made since the first CCIV Bill. We have also noted whether the Revised CCIV Bill has addressed some of our more significant concerns that we had raised in our submissions to Treasury on the exposure draft.
|Corporations Act Section||Subject matter||Provision in Revised CCIV Bill||Allens comments|
|s.1234L(1)||Depositary to have supervisory responsibility||The depositary of a CCIV must take reasonable care to verify that the activities it is required to supervise are carried out in a manner that complies with the CCIV's constitution and the Corporations Act.||
|s.1234P||Breach reporting||The depositary must notify ASIC within 10 business days of becoming aware of or having reasonable suspicion that a breach relating to an activity for which it has supervisory responsibilities has occurred if that breach or suspected breach is or would be, in the opinion of the depositary, a material breach of the Corporations Act.||
|ss.1234D,1234H, para 4.29 -4.59 EM||Independence of depositary (including agents)||The independence requirements for depositaries in s1234D are still under development. However, the explanatory memorandum accompanying the Revised CCIV Bill (the
EM) sets out the proposed independence requirements as a guide to the development of legislation. On that basis, it is proposed that:
|ss.1237C(1)(c)and D(1)(c)||Conflict of duty owned by the CD and its officers||
|ss.1245K – 1245L||Liquid/illiquid sub-funds||In line with the Chapter 5C test for a registered managed investment scheme, a sub-fund is liquid if 80% of the value of its assets are liquid.||The liquid/non-liquid distinction has been retained, despite being notoriously difficult to apply and open to manipulation.|
|s.1232F||Definition of 'retail CCIV' and 'wholesale CCIV'||
|s.1647||Transitional provisions||The first period for reporting to ASIC will start when the Revised CCIV Bill commences, and ends at the next 30 June or 31 December (whichever is earlier).||This transitional period has been introduced as part of the new Revised CCIV Bill. However, further transitional arrangements have not been provided, including whether transitioning from a registered scheme or wholesale unit trust to a CCIV should be facilitated (noting that any transition regime would need to consider tax and stamp duty relief if it were to be in any way palatable).|
The Federal Government is seeking submissions on the draft from interested parties by 11 July 2018. We have been heavily involved in the consultation process over the past few years, and will be preparing an Allens submission on the Revised CCIV Bill. We will also be contributing to submissions by key industry bodies.
It is unclear when the second tranche of the revised legislation will be released, but Treasury has indicated it will cover the remaining substantive areas of the CCIV framework, including external administration, consequential amendments to Chapter 7 and penalty provisions.
Also still in the works is the revised draft of the CCIV tax legislation which, once released, will give us a more complete picture of how the final CCIV framework will look. As we reported in April's Unravelled, there were fundamental issues with the first draft of the CCIV tax legislation. If those issues remain largely unresolved then, given the centrality of taxation to both the genesis and the prospects of the vehicle, we fear that the CCIV will fail to meet the Federal Government's lofty aims and will be rendered a white elephant.
We have written extensively on the CCIV and proposed new limited partnership CIV over the past three years. You can find all of our publications, together with the draft legal and tax legislation, draft ASIC guidance and related Allens submissions on our dedicated CCIV Hub.
- Penny NikoloudisPartner,
Ph: +61 3 9613 8816
- Marc KempPartner, Sector Leader, Funds,
Ph: +61 2 9230 4991
- Geoff SandersPartner,
Ph: +61 3 9613 8673
- James KanabarManaging Associate,
Ph: +61 2 9230 4130
You can leave a comment on this publication below. Please note, we are not able to provide specific legal advice in this forum. If you would like advice relating to this topic, contact one of the authors directly. Please do not include links to websites or your comment may not be published.